I've been on record on this for a while. FutureChurch and the Conference for Pastoral Planning and Council Development (the people who met at Harrah's in Las Vegas) have the same beliefs. See my post from May 9, 2012. Letting a Screenshot Speak for Me.
Thursday, June 27, 2013
Tuesday, June 25, 2013
What Should be Done? Part 2, Updated.
So we
know what the "pastoral planners" say about Church disputes. Try to
win. If you don't, do what you want and just keep calling yourself Catholic
anyway. That's one perspective, here's another.
What
does the archbishop think? I don't know, of course, but I think I can figure it
out. You can decide if you think I have the right answer.
I think
the archbishop thinks that the Church has important work to do for God in this
world and the only reason it has physical things is to do that work. That's the
only reason the Church can justify having land, buildings, money, anything. The
Church shouldn't have fewer physical things, less "resources" in the
planners' language, than it needs to do its job, and it shouldn't have more,
either.
I think
the archbishop thinks that the Archdiocese of Philadelphia has too many
parishes. There's too much land, too many buildings to take care of. He wants
to do God's work in the world. If the Church needs a particular church building
to do its work, then taking care of that building is God's work. If the Church
doesn't need the building then taking care of it takes you away from God's
work.
Now we
have the number of parishes appropriate for the number of people going to Mass
in 1960. Archbishop Chaput's idea is not to keep the buildings up and hope that
the people come back. His idea is to promote and teach and practice the Holy
Catholic Faith that comes to us from the Apostles. If you want him to close no
parishes you'd have to convince him that we have the right number of parishes
now.
Do we
have too many parishes? I think we probably do. But what I really think is that
Archbishop Chaput thinks we do. He's a guy who is not ashamed of what he
believes. When he writes something, he puts his name on it. His writing is
direct. He might be right or he might be wrong, but there's no way not to know
what he thinks. This is in contrast to the planners who very rarely ever put a
name on anything, and write in such a convoluted fashion that you can't figure
out what, if anything, a particular sentence means. Ever try to read the report
of the Blue Ribbon school closing panel?
And I
think it's relevant that the archbishop didn't volunteer for this, the Pope
just plopped him down here and asked him to be bishop. I think he's very
willing to go wherever God wants him to go and do whatever God wants done, but
his attitude is not that he's here to get us to like him. He's here to do God's
will. He's not going to change course because we're mad at him. He'll only
change course if he thinks he's made a mistake.
So what
should he do? Well, let's say that God allowed him to consult with the Twelve
Apostles. There're in a conference room at 222 and the archbishop walks in.
He
says, "Thanks for coming to help me out with this difficult problem."
Peter replies, "We'll be getting back to the Beatific Vision real soon, so
just tell us the problem. We can be friends when you get there. If you
do."
"OK,
well, it's like this, I was working away, really happy, and getting things done
and preaching the Gospel out in a mountainous area in the
middle of the country and then the Holy Father asked me to drop all that and
come to Philadelphia to be bishop. And I said I would give up that
ministry and come here." He pauses.
Peter
says, "Good decision, kid. Go on." The archbishop tries to start
talking fast. "I decided that I'd go to Philadelphia and do my best for
Jesus. I'd do all the stuff I did up in the mountains. I'd preach the gospel,
encourage the Catholics, administer the sacraments . . .
" "Good goal," said Peter.
"Well,
these people here talk funny and think different and are always fighting and
think that where they're from is super important. If some guy is from Upper
Darby, for example, and you say he's from Darby, he gets all bent out of shape,
and the fighting just doesn't stop and nobody will tell me what's going on . .
."
Peter
interrupts. "Listen, kid, I know you've read Acts. Just assume we know
what's in Acts, too, and get to the point. What's the problem? What are we here
for?"
"Well,
they have a lot of parishes, with churches and houses and land and stuff and
I've decided it's too much stuff and too expensive to keep up and I have to get rid of some of it so we can
concentrate on doing the Lord's work."
Peter
says, "That's your problem?" And, of course the archbishop is
embarrassed by that and says, "You don't understand. These Philadelphians
really like their parishes. Really, really like their parishes. They're not like normal people. They just stay in one place. They don't grow up
and go to college in another state and graduate school in another and get a job
in another and never go back where they started because by that time their
parents have moved to another state. If I ask someone if he's been in the
parish a long time, he'll say 'No, your Eminence or Excellency or whatever, we
didn't move here until 1982, I'm really from St. Madeline's.' He says the
'whatever,' too, of course. If I told them I needed a census, they'd all go
back to their 'home parishes.' "
Peter
says, "You don't have to tell me anymore about Philadelphians. Paul, who I
notice somehow avoided making this trip, had plenty of trouble with them too.
You know, you don't have to like them, you just have to love them. Now is that
it?" The archbishop responds, "I think so, you see . . ."
Peter
says "OK, I think we have it. I'm not sure about these 'states' you
talk about, though. If they're spiritual states you might have to run it by me
again. OK, then. The problem is you have trouble with Philadelphians, they like
their parishes, you're the bishop, and think they should have fewer?"
"Yep, that's it."
So
Peter turns and looks at the Apostles, and the Apostles look at him, and they
all look at each other like "He called us out for this?" And some of
them sort of shrug and Peter turns to him and says "It's easy. You decide
how many parishes have to go, then pick them at random. Put the names in a hat
or something, and just pick them at random. You're still using hats, aren't
you? I just ask because I haven't seen any this trip. Well anyway set it up so
everybody's got the same chance of losing what they love, so less resentment.
Even the rich people might lose something. If you close enough parishes some
rich people are sure to lose, then everybody'll be happy."
The
archbishop says, "I'm not sure." Peter says, "Have you read Acts
or what?" The archbishop says "It goes against the mores of modern
people to make decisions that way." Peter says, "Inculturate it any
way you want. We're headed back to the BV. Maybe we'll see you there
eventually."
Well,
if you've read this far, here's the moral of my little story. If the archbishop
thinks that God's work will be advanced by closing parishes, he'll close
parishes. If you say you love your parish he'll say he can't help you because
we all say we love our parish. If you say that closing your parish is arbitrary
he'll think that's as good as can be done. St. Peter recommended arbitrary.
The
fact is, though, these closings are worse than arbitrary, they're unjust. There
was an unCatholic pastoral planning machine running when he got here. The archbishop asked
the people he found here if he should use the machine to pick the
parishes to be closed. They said yes. I wish he asked me, but he didn't. He just
told the planners to knock it off with their stupid slogans like "Faith in the
Future" and "Call to Conversion and Holiness." To get the archbishop to change his mind you'd have to get him to
change his mind. The pastoral planning process is not designed to promote and
teach the Holy Catholic Faith that comes to us from the Apostles. It's designed
to promote the huggy, worldly, feel-good religion that the planners used to
call "the Spirit of Vatican II." It's to free up "resources"
to pay "pastoral ministers" and social workers. That's not the faith
of Vatican II, though. The faith of the Church, the faith of all the councils,
is something else.
Closing
St. Joachim is part of the bureaucrats' plan to withdraw the Church from the
world of working class Philadelphia. They don't feel guilty because they think
they might replace it with social workers. I think the plan's not in accord
with the archbishop's religious beliefs. I think if he comes to agree he'll
find a way to reverse this, because I think he would do anything for his faith.
Update: This is an explanation of the reference to St. Paul and the Philadelphians. The Church at Philadelphia is one of the seven churches of Asia Minor from the book of Revelation. It is said to have "patient endurance." Rev. 3:10. Whether scholars actually say that there was a church in Philadelphia because of St. Paul's work when he lived in Ephesus, or modern Philadelphians just like to say that scholars say that, I don't know. But anyway I hypothesize that St. Paul had a hard time with them, since he had a hard time with about everybody, and they were, after all, Philadelphians. Here is something that didn't make it into the original post:
"And buck up kid. Paul had his problems with them, too. You're lucky those letters are lost. You wouldn't want to have to read from the Third Letter to the Philadelphians with a bunch of kids in church. But he got it all straightened out before he was through, and by the time it was young John's turn to write about them they got nothing but good marks. You may turn this around yet."
Additional Update: What is in Paul's Third Epistle to the Philadelphians? The big spectator sports in the Greek world at this time were horse racing and chariot racing. The racing would take place in a stadium called a hippodrome where, of course, the fans would root for their chosen team. After Constantinople was founded and became the most important city in the Greek world, for example, four hippodrome factions developed, the Greens, the Blues, the Whites and the Reds. Part of the tradition was that the fans wore clothes of the appropriate color to the hippodrome. In Philadelphia one of the hippodrome factions was the Oranges. They had 48 traditional chants that were to be used according to the race situation, the opponent and how mad the fans were. Some of these chants were really bad. I mean like Palestra 1974 bad. So Paul had to discuss each one and explain why a Christian, could, or more often, could not, participate in the chant. He approved six, and disapproved 42, explaining that for the approved six, that they could only be used jocularly, only at the hippodrome when a race was in progress, and never, ever be said if the chanter actually meant any word of the chant. If we still had the Third Letter we'd have a good insight into the questions of Christian ethics involved in being a sports fan, (or a sports bettor) but still, we're probably better off without it. Translation would be quite a challenge, beyond the concern that St. Peter expressed. Even the Philadelphians found it embarrassing and only read it in church once every third year.
What Should be Done? Part 1.
The closing of St. Joachim is a very
difficult thing. It's tough to write about. It's tough to think about. I wish
the problem would just go away.
But it's much tougher for the people
of St. Joachim than it is for me. What would I do if I were in their place?
What would I do if the Church for unjust reasons took something away from me
that I loved very much, that I legitimately loved very much? I don't really
know of course. We don't really know how we would react to something big, until
something big comes along. So I don't know how I would react. I can try to
figure out how I hope I would react when the trial came, and if I publish this
post I'm going to have to figure that out and write it down, too. But this post
is about something else. I'm going to give the planners' answer to the
question. The planners have already said what you should do when the Church
does one thing and you want another.
In 2001 the archdiocesan planners
and the Conference for Pastoral Planning and Council Development sponsored
something called “Regional Workshop for Parish Pastoral Councils,” at
Archbishop Carroll High School. A man named Mark Fischer gave a talk. He
referred to other speakers as “experts” on parish councils. He was giving his
talk based on his experience on the parish council “at St. Joseph Church in
Berkeley, California.” Before he became a member of that parish council in 1983
“I knew almost nothing about parish pastoral councils.” The content of his talk
is based on what he learned on that parish council.
He said that the "Church has
given pastoral councils a threefold function. It is to investigate, ponder, and
make recommendations about pastoral matters. Councilors have a right to do this
job. If a pastor is not asking the pastoral council to exercise its proper
function, then the situation is dysfunctional. Parishioners should seek to
remedy it. If their efforts are unsuccessful, they are not without recourse. As
Father Richard C. Cunningham has written, 'Ultimately they still possess the
power of numbers, of finances, of public opinion, of sensus fidelium, of
conscience, and the radical power of shaking the dust from their feet as they
exit.' "
Eventually St. Joseph Parish in
Berkeley, California got a new pastor. He thought that the parish council had
been improperly elected and he installed a new one. The old parish council
picketed the church.
The Philadelphia planners have a
newsletter, “InFormation,” which is subtitled “News for Pastoral Planners and
Those Making the Plan a Reality.” That is, it's for the people in charge (them)
and for the people doing what they're told (us). It's not the topic of this
post, but on the front page of issue 3 of 2011 it says that parishes can hire
“professional facilitators,” trained by the planners, to "facilitate"
parish self-study. The unnamed author says “In a parish self study the
fee would be negotiated between the parish and the facilitator. For budget
purposes I would estimate $50-100 an hour.” I wonder if parishes that hired
these "professional facilitators" did better than those that didn't,
and I wonder if some "professional facilitators" had a better record
of saving parishes than others.
That newsletter also included “a
partial reprint from the monthly newsletter November 2011 A Service of the
Parish Evaluation Project Milwaukee, Wisconsin.” This is the beginning:
Hanging In
There
We promised to tell a few of the stories of those who are
struggling with the Church but are choosing to remain part of it.
These stories will eventually find their way into a forthcoming
book, The Catholic Dilemma – Remain or
Move On: A Resource for Parish Renewal. The interviews cover a wide range
of topics, including authority, the role of women, justice, sexuality and spirituality,
to name but a few. One person wrote, “Many of us have chosen to stay but on our
‘terms.’ We celebrate with the pastoral church and disregard the institutional
Church.”
So the planners' answer is clear. If
you have a serious dispute with the Church on an important issue, you should do
whatever you think is right and just keep calling yourself Catholic.
"Celebrate" what you want. "Disregard" what you don't.
"Remain or move on." Use "the power of numbers, of finances, of
public opinion, of sensus fidelium, of conscience" or "the radical
power of shaking the dust from" your feet as you exit.
This makes sense unless you think
the Catholic Church is the one true Church established by Christ. If you have
that belief you have a problem. The planners' solution just won't work for you.
I couldn't do it. So I guess I'll have to come back to this topic.
Sunday, June 23, 2013
Thursday, June 20, 2013
My Silence
I haven't
been writing about my topic because I find it so depressing. Good things are
being destroyed by people with a bad ideology. The people of St Joachim,
though, seem to have gotten me energized. Their blog is here. They are also on Facebook, but I'm not
so I don't know how to tell you how to find them there. The Philadelphia Church
Project has a great post on the parish closings, with a very appropriate title, here.
One reason I find this all so sad is
that I am sure that this would be much easier for everyone if the people who
are supposed to be helping the archbishop would just help the archbishop. I
don't think he's afraid of work or of making decisions. If he had competent
help and accurate information things would be different. I think he belongs to
only one organization which would have a conference at Harrah's in Las Vegas.
Prayer seems to be the only answer.
St. Ambrose pray for us.
St. Charles Borromeo pray for us.
St. John Neumann pray for us.
Pictures and Words
Here's a picture that pretty much says
everything I'm trying to say with this blog.
St. Joachim
Here's a sad fact I just discovered. The
organization that the Catholic planning bureaucrats all belong to is the
Conference for Pastoral Planning and Council Development. They just had their
annual convention in, of course, Fabulous Las Vegas. This
organization establishes the ideology that allows the bureaucrats to
identify the bad parishes that must be destroyed. See their Las Vegas agenda. Well, just to
make things stranger, their mailing address is right in the St. Joachim
neighborhood. Zip Code 19149. 19149 is so
close to the Bridge-Pratt El stop that I'd call it Frankford, but I know people
up there take neighborhood borders seriously, and it might not actually be
Frankford. Anyway, you can learn an awful lot about the beliefs and ideology of
the church and school closers on their website. It seems
that the people who got the ball rolling on the unjust decision to close St.
Joachim may think they know a lot about the area. It is very strange that the
mailing address of their organization is so close to one of their targets.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


