From 1852 to 1860 St. John Neumann was the bishop of the
Diocese of Philadelphia and worked tirelessly to open Catholic schools. In 1863 the parish of St. Peter the Apostle,
where St. John had been buried, built a school. In 1916 the parish built a new
school, but incorporated the cornerstone from the 1863 building. In 2012 the “pastoral
planners” of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia tried to close the parish school,
open for almost 150 years, to replace it with one of their regional schools.
Because of the work of the parishioners of St. Laurentius in Fishtown, the planners were
unable to close St. Laurentius school, leaving the planners with no excuse to make St.
Peter’s the site of a regional school, and the parish school survived. A defeat
for the planners and a victory for the Church.
Friday, November 23, 2012
What Am I Up To?
The simplest way to explain the behavior of any bureaucratic
organization is to assume that it is controlled by a cabal of its enemies.
Robert
Conquest’s Third Law of Politics
The purpose of this post is to try to explain what it is I’m
trying to do with this blog. In the most narrow sense the answer is easy. I
think that the “pastoral planners” of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia have an
ideology that controls what they want to do to the Catholic Church in
Philadelphia. They pretend that they have no ideology at all. They act like
they’re just neutral planners with no agenda. If you read their stuff it’s
clear that they have an agenda, and I don’t think it’s a Catholic one. I think
that the more people understand their actual ideology, the less likely the
planners are to succeed, so I try to tell people about it.
I got interested in this issue in the summer of 2011. The archdiocesan bureaucrats were closing St. Kevin’s school in Springfield. The
dispute was weird. The school’s supporters would be identified in the
newspapers by name and they would explain exactly why they thought the school
was financially viable and worth saving. Their opponents were not named in the papers and their
motives for closing the school was only explained in the most vague and general
terms. The pastor, for example, would make statements about why the archdiocese
wanted the school closed, but he didn’t say he was speaking for himself, he was
relaying the opinion of unnamed archdiocesan employees. Spokesmen for the archdiocese would issue
statements vaguely saying that the school had to be closed because it didn’t
have enough kids in it, vaguely implying that there was some financial
reasoning involved, but they didn’t claim to be the decision-makers, they were
merely the spokesmen for the decision-makers. The archdiocesan employees who
were actually making the decision were never quoted, never named. There was never
any explanation for why it was so urgent, why it had to be closed right away,
why small schools were so intolerable.
Cardinal Rigali wouldn’t meet with the parishioners.
Eventually the parishioners bought a billboard on the Schuylkill Expressway
asking for a meeting, and he agreed to meet with him. It took a while to
actually happen because the Cardinal was traveling. When he finally met with
the parishioners he told them that archdiocesan employees had decided to close
their school and he wasn’t going to interfere with their decision.
The most common explanation for this campaign against St.
Kevin’s was money. People would write letters accusing the Church of caring
about nothing but money and taking the school away from the people of St. Kevin’s
for reasons of greed.
I didn’t think they were right, but I had no alternative
explanation. I started a research project to find out. For one thing, not much
money was saved by closing the school. There was no financial reason for doing
it immediately. Even more important, I thought, was that closing the school
didn’t save any money for the archdiocese. The school was run by the parish. It
didn’t cost the archdiocese any money at all.
One of the things I found in my research was the blog “Boston
Catholic Insider.” I wished that there was a similar blog for the Archdiocese
of Philadelphia. I wished that someone on the inside would explain what was
going on, who was doing it and why. After a while I realized that was not going
to happen. Nobody was going to provide direct evidence about what the bureaucrats
were up to or what their motives were.
I kept working and eventually read enough of the public
writings of the pastoral planners that I think I know what they’re up to. Since
no insider was going to step up, I would be the outsider who had learned something
and was willing to tell people about it.
Since Vatican II the Church has had the problem of people inside
the Church trying to replace the Catholic faith with something else. James
Hitchcock’s “Decline and Fall of Radical Catholicism” is, I think, one of the
best books on this phenomenon. Msgr.
George Kelly’s “Battle for the American Church” is another great book on the
topic. It’s also a theme that runs through Philip Lawler’s “The Faithful
Departed,” a book about the history of the Boston Archdiocese. I think that if
the Conference for Pastoral Planning and Council Development had existed when
Dr. Hitchcock and Msgr. Kelly wrote their books it would have earned a
chapter in both. Instead it flies under the radar, pretending like it’s
completely without a spiritual agenda, when it most assuredly has one.
One thing about being an outsider is that it’s easier for me
to keep this impersonal. I don’t know any private facts about any of these
people. I’m very willing to admit that they think they’re doing good. They don’t
think that the religion the Pope promotes has anything useful for the modern
world. They think that those who can should adopt the “Gather Faithfully Together”
religion. I think they’re wrong. I have no opinion regarding whether they are
bad people. That’s not my business. I’m not supposed to be judging them.
I don’t think that original sin has left a bigger mark on
Church bureaucrats than it has on anyone else, but I don’t think it’s left less
of a mark, either. Church bureaucrats have the same tendency to employ the
resources of their employer to advance their own goals, as opposed to the goals
of the organization, that all bureaucrats do. Robert Conquest didn’t know any
of the employees of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, but his Third Law of Politics
is an exact description of their behavior. Nobody thinks priests, for example, should be
allowed to do whatever they want without supervision. All of us have checks on
our behavior. Things restrain us from doing what we want to do, and we are
required to do what we’re supposed to do, especially at work. I just think that
it can’t be assumed that because lay Church employees are not motivated by money,
that they are therefore doing the right thing.
There are two facts regarding the management of the Catholic
Church that are undeniable. First, objective observation from the outside
indicates that things are in a shambles. Second, the people doing the managing
act like they are not failing, but are succeeding. The explanation is not that
the Church bureaucrats are unaware of what’s going on around them. The goals they think they are successfully working toward are just different from the goals most outside observers think they have.
Friday, March 9, 2012
Letting a Screenshot Speak for Me
I've had complaints that my posts are too wordy, but pointing out the planners' values isn't easy. This post, though, won't require much typing. This screenshot shows a search of "Conference for Pastoral Planning and Council Development" on the FutureChurch website. It makes my point for me.
More from St. John Neumann
One of the saint's biographers, Father W. Frean, C.SS.R., noted
that the “results which attended Neumann’s efforts were not attained without
stiff opposition from some quarters. For example, the pastor of St. Michael’s
refused to build a school, saying that the undertaking was an impossible one in the circumstances in which he found himself. The bishop
who was always very mild, but equally firm when God’s honor and the salvation
of souls demanded it, quietly informed the parish priest that if he did not do
this work, then he would find somebody else to do it for him.” Blessed John Neumann: The Helper of the
Afflicted, pp. 154-155 (Majellan Press 1963).
Things are different now. If a pastor says that it
is possible to keep a school open, his opinion is disregarded in favor of the conclusions of the lay bureaucrats. A priest’s career would be furthered by closing a school, not
by opening one. And the “salvation of souls” is a subject that is not addressed
by employees of the archdiocese.
Friday, March 2, 2012
Denouncing "New Doctrine" in the Inquirer
Now that the crisis is over for most schools I was
hoping that some reporting and commentary would appear in the papers that would
let people know what had happened and why, but there's been very little. Few reporters seem interested in doing more than printing whatever public
spokesmen happen to say.
Some reporters have brought out some interesting
facts, and I’ll try to highlight them in some future posts, but in the field of
commentary there’s only been one thing written that’s at all insightful, and it
appeared in the Inquirer of all places. I think the editors may have perceived it to be somehow
useful against the Church because they took its tone to be strident and maybe a little revolutionary.
A.J. Thomson, from Fishtown, was well-positioned to
learn something from this fight, and he did. He was instrumental in
the successful appeal of the plan to “merge” St. Laurentius with St. Peter the
Apostle, and have the regional school at St. Peter’s. I think that one may have
been important to the planners. I think they would have loved to have made the
Catholic school at the shrine of St. John Neumann into a regional rather than a
parish school. It certainly seems that their plan to close St Laurentius was
unnecessary, even under their criteria, since they were unable to come up with a basis for rejecting the
appeal.
His column appeared in the Inquirer on February 26.
Here’s an example of a sentence that I'm not quite sure about. “And like any
struggle for one’s identity, it made us better.” Well, I certainly agree that
it was an inspiring struggle. I also agree that it made us better. It got lots
of people together in a good way. Those who won accomplished something very
much worth doing. Those on our side who did not save their schools were also fighting for the right. But for
their “identity?” That strikes me as the kind of psychobabbly word that the
planners use. Maybe, though, he used it to mean “heritage.”
I very much liked this paragraph, which shows he’s
paying attention.
The archdiocesan officials who delivered the news of
the reprieves looked as if they were in the receiving line at their own
funerals. Their morose expressions underscored the vast distance between those
who want Catholic education and those who have concocted a Byzantine system for
telling us we can't have it.
The archbishop was happy. The rich guys were happy.
The politicians were happy. The planners and their minions weren’t. They didn’t
start this process to get lots of money at the last minute and save schools.
They started it to close schools. They don’t like the high schools being saved,
and they don’t like all those grade schools’ appeals being granted, showing how
shoddy and unsupported their “work” was. Mr. Thomson knows that the people he and
his friends fought against to keep St. Laurentius open were not trying to lose. They
were trying to win. Maybe the archbishop noticed and learned something from the way his employees acted when they were announcing the saved grade schools.
Mr. Thomson also has
spotted the most important issue. He knows that the excuse for the mass closing
of grade schools makes no sense.
The new doctrine
suggesting that a parish shouldn't support a school seems to come from a
mail-order business-school curriculum, not the tradition of Catholicism as we
know it in Philadelphia. The paramount aim of our church should be to educate
and instill our faith in as many of its young people as possible. For
centuries, it has been. Only now is the principle being questioned by a few.
Grade schools don't get money from the archdiocese. They used to be supported by the parishes. If Catholicism is a
religion, there’s no reason why parishes can’t support schools. St. John
Neumann’s whole idea was that parishes would support schools. The planners
never explain why parishes shouldn’t support schools, they just assert it.
I’ve got no business
quibbling with Mr. Thomson. He said, in the pages of the Inquirer, no less, in
the face of the violent disagreement of the entire archdiocesan bureaucracy,
save only the guy at the very top: “The paramount aim of our church should be
to educate and instill our faith in as many of its young people as possible.”
The planners have many, many goals that come before that one. I’m going to go
through with the quibble, though. This “new doctrine” comes from the Conference
for Pastoral Planning and Council Development and the Archdiocese of Philadelphia's
Office for Research and Planning. They don't preach this new doctrine for
business reasons. No business would deliberately damage its main source of new
customers. They preach their new doctrine because they want to be in an
entirely different business. This is an effective plan for getting the Church where they want it to be.
One more quibble. Mr.
Thomson compares the fight to the Civil War and Lincoln’s problem in getting
his generals to fight. He says that “it is time to ditch the McClellans―the
generals who shrink from a challenge,” and: “We should be asking the archbishop
to promote the Grants and Shermans.” Certainly the leaders in the fight to save
schools did the right thing. Leaping into the breach on very short notice and
putting up a good fight deserves praise. But what does Mr. Thomson want to be promoted
to? It may be this request that got his column into the Inquirer. They may have
thought he is fighting to reorganize the Church along the lines of Congregationalism,
or something. And some of the heroes in this battle were
not lay people. Father Olson of Bonner and Prendie certainly distinguished
himself in the fight.
More importantly, our
problem is not that we have too many McClellans. I wish the planners were more
timid. They faced the challenge of a new archbishop who might take away their control
of the diocese. They decided to meet that challenge as Michael Corleone would. They put together a plan to “settle all family business” on one day before the
new archbishop knew his new diocese.
Anyway, Mr. Thomson did
a great job. He saved his school, and he learned enough in the process to write
the most perceptive article on the school closings that I’ve seen published
anywhere, and he got it published in the Inquirer. I hope he heeds his own call to continue to fight for Catholic schools.
Mission Statement
The planners are quite dogmatic that a
mission statement is a requirement for every undertaking, so I’ve added one to
the sidebar.
Update: It’s been pointed
out to me that the planners now say you also need a “vision.” A mission
statement is without vitality nowadays if it doesn’t have a vision to go
along with it. So I have a committee going through a five stage series of
meetings to come up with one. There’s a lot of disagreement on the topic right
now. Some members of the committee are fighting hard for: “The paramount aim of our church should be to educate
and instill our faith in as many of its young people as possible.” Others are
pushing: “The employees of the archdiocese do
not believe that they are failing at running a Catholic school system. They
think they are succeeding in achieving goals of their own.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
